NeuroPsyFi


The Brain Science Behind the Movies

  • Home
  • Credits
    • About Mary Spiers
  • Behind the Scenes
    • BrainResources
    • For Writers and Film Makers >
      • The Writer's Brain Lab Blog
    • For Teachers
  • Reviews
  • Movies

My Name is Khan

4/18/2013

22 Comments

 
Picture
A Muslim man with Asperger’s Disorder must deliver a message to the president to reclaim the woman he loves.

Rizwan Khan is a young Indian man with Asperger’s Disorder. A literal interpretation of an angry statement from his estranged wife Mandira leads him on a quest to deliver a personal message to the President of the United States that he is not a terrorist. Khan’s quest to fix things with Mandira leads him into adventure, misfortune and friendship as his Asperger’s Disorder, and with it its proclivity towards restricted interests and obliviousness to social cues, both helps and hinders Khan’s efforts to win Mandira back. 

Neuropsychological Review
Julia Grayer

My Name Is Khan isn’t a film about Asperger’s Disorder; rather it is a film about a man with Asperger’s Disorder. Before we ever meet Rizwan Khan, we learn from a placard... 

that he suffers from this developmental disorder. The film never explicitly explains what Asperger’s is, but as the story unfolds it becomes clear that Khan is different from his family and peers and that this difference stems from his disorder. Nevertheless, the greatest triumph of the film is that it portrays the condition not as something that limits Khan, but rather as something that enriches both him and everyone around him.

A hallmark of Asperger’s Disorder is that people with the disorder often interpret language very literally, and it is this literal interpretation of language that sets Khan’s journey into motion.  After he and his wife Mandira suffer a personal tragedy, Mandira orders Khan to leave their marriage. When he asks her in innocence, “When should I come back?” (1:29:35), she answers that he should return only after he personally tells the US President that he is not a terrorist. Mandira surely does not expect Khan to actually do this, but Khan takes her at her word. Naive to the dangers that could befall a Muslim man with a mission to track down the President of the United States, Khan packs his bag and heads to the airport.

While Khan inevitably suffers various setbacks on his quest (including eventually being held as an enemy combatant), turning back without completing his mission never enters Khan’s mind. Like many people with Asperger’s, Khan has a tendency towards restricted interests, and in his case his interest is to repair things. He is resolved to “fix” his current problem (getting his wife back) with the same singularity of focus he has displayed since his childhood when he was the unofficial village handyman. Even though his current problem is much greater than a broken clock or car engine, Khan is just as determined to make things right. This theme, of Khan trying to fix what is broken, is repeated throughout the film, even when the problems of the world become bigger than any one person can take on.

While Khan’s proclivity to fix things, including his current situation, does stem from his disorder, this doesn’t mean that he isn’t also motivated by his emotions. The film succeeds in making it abundantly clear that Khan is highly capable of love, loyalty and feeling. From flashbacks to his childhood with his mother to his courtship with Mandira and his eventual bond with her son Sameer, who Khan refers to as “my only best friend” (1:47:08), the film’s portrayal of Khan as a man capable of deep human connection refreshingly works against the stereotype that people with autism spectrum disorders are unable to form meaningful relationships.

In fact, throughout his journey Khan forms countless friendships, and he is almost universally accepted despite his sometimes-obvious differences. People with Asperger’s Disorder have trouble understanding social norms, which we see in Khan when, for instance, his neighbor asks if he likes her cooking and he responds, “no, not at all” (1:13:16) and when he indicates to Mandira that a snack she is about to eat will make her fat (37:12). In the real world, these behaviors would likely be interpreted as rude or insulting, but Khan is hardly ever reprimanded for these faux pas.  Ideally people would react with this level of understanding, but it does at times require a willful suspension of disbelief to accept these interactions as plausible.

Although it is not currently a criterion for a diagnosis of Asperger’s, many people with the disorder suffer from sensory difficulties. Khan is no exception. We learn through flashbacks that from an early age Khan has an intense dislike for the color yellow (10:03), has trouble hugging his mother (21:10) and is easily overwhelmed by noises. It is in fact when he is overwhelmed and disoriented by the noises and colors on the streets of San Francisco that he meets Mandira for the first time (27:35). This is one example of how Khan’s Asperger’s happens to serve him well on his journey- if not for his disorder he likely wouldn’t have met Mandira, and her immediate sympathy with his situation shows both Khan and the audience that Mandira is good person worthy of Khan’s devotion.

Some of the most heart-wrenching parts of the film are the scenes when Khan is being interrogated for his meticulous mapping of the President’s itinerary. Khan doesn’t understand why sometimes the temperature in his cell is freezing and why at other times it is boiling, why no one will tell him the time of day so he can pray, and why the lights don’t work properly. In voiceover as he composes a letter to Mandira we learn that he has offered to repair these things; he has no idea that he is being subjected to what many would call torture. And when he is being questioned, he says with all earnestness that he wishes he had studied up on al-Qaeda so he could be more helpful to his interrogators.  It is scenes like this that remind the viewer that as smart and capable as someone with Asperger’s can be, the deficits are real and can lead to situations that are unsafe and life-threatening. In one of the early flashbacks in the film, a youthful Khan returns home to his mother repeating anti-Hindu propaganda. Dismayed to hear this coming from her son, his mother sits Khan down and, using pictures, teaches him that there are two kinds of people in the world, “Good people who do good deeds. And bad people who do bad,” (13:16) and that that is all that matters. Her overt point is that people shouldn’t be judged based on race or religion, but she could easily have also been teaching him that people shouldn’t be judged for having a disability. Thereafter, Khan makes it his mission to seek out and fight for the good people he meets in life, and in so doing he himself becomes a force for good. Ultimately the humanity that Khan puts out into the world is stronger than the forces that are trying to hold him back. While My Name Is Khan is not always one-hundred-percent true to life (people’s reactions to Khan are unfortunately not like “real people” would tend to behave) and at 165 minutes, half of which are with Hindu subtitles, it can at times feel long and meandering, in the end My Name Is Khan is an inspiring story of the power of love and loyalty despite perceived disability. 
22 Comments
Ruchika Bhatnagar
11/24/2013 10:38:39 pm

My name is Khan is a very emotional movie with the main character Rizwan having Asperger’s and being Muslim. The film contains very touching scenes showing the true struggle of being a Muslim after the 9/11 terrorist attacks. Both as an average movie watcher as well as a student who has taken a neuropsychology class I can appreciate the movie in a different way.
In our class we have discussed Asperger’s as being a high-functioning form of Autism. This is exactly what the movie portrays. The movie shows Khan struggling to begin a relationship with his future wife, his struggles of being a salesman, and it shows his struggles of maintaining the relationship with his wife. The movie shows a non-exaggerated version of what a person with Asperger’s may have to deal with and overall I agree with the analysis of the movie.

Reply
Ashna Patel
11/24/2013 10:54:54 pm

After reading the review on the movie My Name is Khan, by Julia Grayer, I realized that a lot of our opinions on the movie were quite similar. Although, this movie was created to show the difficulties Muslims and Indians faced because of the terrorist attacks of September 11th; the movie did a fairly well job on portraying their lead character as a victim of Asperger's disorder. It's an extremely touching movie, the troubles he faces, the stereotypes, and the racism, help create a heart touching atmosphere. I also like how Julia Grayer mentioned specific times in the movie where the symptoms of his disorder were portrayed very nicely. I watched this movie a long time ago, and with her descriptions, I can go back and remember exactly what shes talking about. It is a Bollywood movie so it was more focused on the full out spicy drama, songs, romance and so on. I do think that it could have done a better job on actually talking about the asperger's disorder and making a bigger deal out of it. Almost like giving it more importance and making it a part of the film.

Reply
Kim Chatman
11/27/2014 06:04:20 pm

Loved this film. Touched me personally as a mother to a young adult son with Aspergers. I do think the character Rizvan was portrayed with a moderate case of Aspergers even high functioning autism..now defined under Autism Spectrum Disorders umbrella and new DSM..and my son agreed as well. Many high functioning Aspie individuals do indeed have ritualistic patterns and preferences, sensory issues, have a difficult time reading others emotions , interacting in social settings and are often very literal. Yet unless you know them well or spend time with them regularly , they may have accommodated these differences sufficiently enough to "hide" them . And Aspie folks are often very, very bright.
But this was an incredible movie, about an incredible young man- finding a happy life and openly practicing a peaceful form of his chosen religion. I agree..until we can lay down these differences and stop violence and fighting ..practicing GOOD, peace and love instead..our world is not always a very happy or safe place right now. I will recommend this film to others..even with the subtitles..and my old eyes needing bi-focals now.

Reply
Vishu link
6/11/2015 02:08:38 pm

my name is khan was very nice movie
i saw the movie on TV

Reply
Diana randall
1/7/2016 08:00:09 pm

Just saw the movie.I cried more then once.Fiction or non fiction doesn't matter. It was a really good movie.

Reply
Mansi Patel
2/14/2016 03:32:18 pm

The movie, My Name is Khan is an exceptional movie that addresses many aspects to our society in an urgent and informative way. As a Hindu, Indian- American woman I related to this movie and believe that many more people should watch it. I think that the movie addresses three important subjects: Hindu -Muslim relations, racial profiling and Autism Spectrum Disorder. First, I would like to review the ASD portrayal in the movie. I was assigned to watch this movie and class assignment for my psychology class PSY 450 (Autism Spectrum Disorders) at Drexel University. Throughout the course, we have been learning about the developmental disorder and everything that it entails. From what I saw the movie, it was portrayed pretty correctly. The main character Rizwan was sensitive to loud noises, hated hugs and the color yellow. Also, what I thought was amazing is that his ASD was the thing that got him towards his goal. As we all know, that autistic individuals often show perseverance when they have a goal in mind (and that is what got him to meet the president). I believe that the racial profiling in the movie was shown correctly. Unfortunately, after the 9/11 attacks many people of the Muslim faith (and brown people in general) were shown hatred. Many people changed their name, and stopped wearing hijabs. Hindu and Muslim relations was shown quite accurately in the movie. This is probably because it is a Bollywood movie made by Indians themselves. It was significant to have a Hindu woman and Muslim man get married in the movie.

Reply
Fatima
3/6/2016 07:51:15 pm

I totally agree with Julia that the move is about khan with asparagus not a move about asparagus, we do understand that khan is not normal being while watching the movie. I noticed that khan takes all the words literally and focus all his power in making what he has been told to do; I think this is a significant reason why he is very smart. Khan has a very good memory as he memories history very well. He does not understand the common norms, when to flatter and when to tell the truth. He sometimes acts as if no one is around him, he does not sense the public opinion about what he does. I do not know if I can call this confidence or not. Khan gets very nervous when there are crowds and loud sounds around him. Such as when the train passes he cannot handle the train sound. I know that he probably hears it louder than the normal person would do, talking from an experience with a kid with asparagus around me.

Reply
Fatima
3/6/2016 08:49:27 pm

I totally agree with Julia that the movie is about khan with Asperger’s disorder not a movie about Asperger’s disorder. We do understand that khan is not normal being while watching the movie. I noticed that khan takes all the words literally and focuses all his power in making what he has been told to do; I think this is a significant reason why he is very smart. Khan has a very good memory as he memories history very well. He does not understand the common norms, when to flatter and when to tell the truth. He sometimes acts as if no one is around him, he does not sense the public opinion about what he does. I don’t know if I can call this confidence or not. Khan gets very nervous when there are crowds and loud sounds around him. Such as when the train passes he cannot handle the train sound. I know that he probably hears it louder than the normal person would do, talking from an experience with a kid with Asperger’s disorder around me.

Reply
Rebotile Mokone
6/23/2016 04:26:12 pm

I loved the movie even though it made me cry few times and I love how Khan's condition was not exaggerated. I also think that the movie is about a man with ASD and not about ASD, which is great because people forget that people living with this disorder are human beings and not the disorder itself. And that this disease does not define them

Reply
Sump Pump Installation Pico Rivera link
8/4/2022 08:18:29 am

Nice blog you havee

Reply
moviemad link
8/10/2022 04:48:19 am

https://moviemad.be/
watch carter

Reply
moviemad link
8/10/2022 03:47:46 am

https://moviemad.lol/
watch netflix series

Reply
moviemad link
8/10/2022 05:18:35 am

https://moviemad.fun/
watch series

Reply
Movies link
8/30/2022 12:31:44 am

In 2005, the movie version of Walter Scott’s best-selling novel, A Place of Greater Safety, hit the big screen. The story focuses on a young man named Theo James who is living with his mother after a train crash left him in a coma for several years. Theo’s life is torn apart when he discovers that his father died in the same accident. His mother struggles to adjust to her grief and find purpose in her life without Theo’s guidance. Eventually, she sends Theo off to live with a distant relative. Before he departs, though, he meets his father for the first time in years. The meeting does not go as either man expects. All of a sudden, misunderstandings and misconceptions about their family name come to light—namely, that it is synonymous with madness or evil.

Reply
BDLove23 link
10/12/2022 08:16:23 pm

My Name is khan is one of the best movie in sharukh khan's career

Reply
UWatchFree link
4/7/2023 01:14:16 pm

UWatchFree is a movie streaming site with all new Hollywood and Bollywood movies added daily. Watch free movies on https://uwatchfreebe.online/ just come and enjoy the latest full movies online on http://uwatchfree.lat/
https://uwatchfree.city/ is a site where you can watch movies online free in HD without annoying ads watch free add a new movie every day on https://uwatchfree.ro/ also
https://uwatchfree.ink/ is a movie streaming site where u can Watch Free Movies, TV Series and Web series Online on https://uwatchfree.mom/
https://tamilyogi.be/ is a public torrent website of tamil movies

Reply
Shangrilalandforsale link
1/31/2023 11:14:29 am

Thanks for the great information.

Reply
ibomma link
4/7/2023 12:26:50 pm

Search the Telugu Movies Online on https://ibommamovie.cc/ Here you can watch online hd on https://www.ibommamovies.biz/ Download Full HD Movies Free on https://www.ibommamovie.one/
also Watch Telugu Movies online free from https://ibomma.city/ Download the latest movies without Registration at https://movieswood.at/

Reply
ibomma link
6/15/2023 01:58:13 am

This Site Is Very Good.https://ibomma.lat/

Reply
ibomma link
6/17/2023 02:08:34 am

this site is very good

Reply
desi cinemas link
7/5/2023 03:17:18 am

only movies lovers

Reply
Celewish link
9/18/2023 02:37:33 am

One of my favorite movie and this is a nice post. thank you for sharing!

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Movie Review Categories

    All
    12 And Under
    13 To 17
    18 And Over
    Amnesia
    Autism Spectrum
    Brain Injury
    Comedy
    Consciousness
    Dementia
    Encephalitis
    Horror
    Identity Loss
    Korsakoffs
    Prosopagnosia
    Sleep
    Stroke
    Tourettes Syndrome

    RSS Feed

_Thanks to:
Picture
Picture

Contact